You’re ready to ask, now what?

Managing Expectations: The Key to Building Lasting Donor Loyalty

In fundraising, setting the right expectations is essential. Whether you exceed, meet, or fall short of those expectations, your donor’s reaction will be tied to what they anticipated. But why does managing expectations matter so much? As Kevin Gentry points out in this week’s Tip, the way expectations are set and met has a direct impact on your nonprofit’s brand and reputation. And ultimately, that shapes donor loyalty. Why Expectations Matter in Fundraising In public relations, there’s a theory that reactions are overwhelmingly based on expectations. For instance, a sports team expected to lose but manages to come in a close second might be seen as a winner. On the flip side, a team expected to win big but narrowly edges out their rival might still be viewed as a disappointment. It’s all about expectations. The same principle applies to your nonprofit’s brand and reputation. When donors have clear expectations, meeting or exceeding them builds trust and loyalty. Falling short, however, can be detrimental—even if the outcome wasn’t necessarily negative. How Expectations Impact Your Brand Take, for example, the donor thank-you. As Kevin mentioned in a previous Fundraising Tip, the way you thank your donors can set the tone for their entire experience with your organization. Many readers shared stories of disappointment, where their generous gifts were met with inadequate or delayed gratitude. These experiences create unmet expectations, leading to frustration. On the other hand, when organizations consistently meet or exceed donor expectations, they build a loyal base that trusts them to deliver on their promises. This is where successful brand-building truly begins. The Art of Exceeding Expectations Art Ciocca, a renowned brand builder, once said, “Real brands are determined by consumers. What makes a real brand is consumer recognition and loyalty.” His advice? Always be “other-directed.” Put your donor or customer at the center of your efforts, and you will create long-term value for your organization. Trust, as we know, is the foundation of brand loyalty. And trust is built by consistently meeting or exceeding expectations. A Lesson in Integrity: Exceeding Expectations at Any Cost Ciocca’s dedication to exceeding expectations was so strong that when faced with a product issue early in his career, he chose integrity over profit. After discovering a harmless sediment in bottles of vermouth at his company, Ciocca ordered the destruction of all 25,000 cases, rather than risk damaging his brand by selling a product that didn’t meet expectations. This decision was costly, but in the long run, it paid off. His flagship product, Franzia, remains the world’s top-selling wine brand to this day. Takeaways for Nonprofits Set Clear Expectations: Make sure your donors know exactly what to expect from your organization. From how you’ll use their donations to how you’ll communicate with them, setting the right expectations from the start can make all the difference. Always Deliver on Promises: Exceeding expectations is a powerful way to build trust. But at the very least, make sure you’re consistently meeting the expectations you set. Prioritize Integrity: Like Ciocca, make decisions that align with your organization’s values, even when it’s costly in the short term. This builds long-term trust and loyalty with your donors. Final Thoughts Managing expectations is more than just meeting goals—it’s about consistently delivering on your promises and exceeding them whenever possible. By doing so, you’ll not only build a strong brand but also foster the kind of donor loyalty that keeps people coming back, year after year.

How to Fundraise During Challenging Economic Times: Lessons from the Experts

In times of economic uncertainty, fundraisers often face an uncomfortable question: How do we continue raising essential funds when the economy takes a downturn? With talk of a potential recession on the horizon, many nonprofit leaders are seeking guidance on how to navigate these difficult waters. Preparing for Economic Challenges in Fundraising Brandon Borke, Vice President of Development at Young Americans for Liberty, recently raised a vital question that many fundraisers are asking: How do we fundraise during a recession? His question highlights a crucial concern, especially for organizations that have thrived during a period of economic growth. Brandon asked about the impact of previous recessions on fundraising and how organizations can not only survive but thrive during economic slowdowns. To answer these questions, I reached out to Kathleen Patten, President and CEO of American Target Advertising, a leader in direct mail fundraising for nonprofit organizations. With decades of experience and a proven track record, Kathleen’s insights offer valuable lessons for any organization preparing for tougher times. Three Storms Facing Fundraisers Today According to Kathleen, we’re already dealing with three major challenges: Inflation: Rising prices are impacting everyone, especially older, fixed-income donors who are typically the most generous. Fuel Prices: High fuel costs increase the price of shipping and distribution, impacting direct mail campaigns and other logistics. Supply Chain Disruptions: These challenges have driven up the cost of materials like paper and limited the ability to innovate in terms of mailing strategies. With these pressures already affecting the fundraising landscape, a potential recession could amplify these issues. As Kathleen warns, “If we get hit with a fourth storm – a recession – the problems will be compounded. And that’s not an easy storm to ride out.” What Fundraisers Can Do to Weather the Storm Despite these challenges, Kathleen offers key strategies to help organizations continue to thrive: Focus on New Donor Acquisition: Even in tough times, prospecting for new donors remains essential. Organizations should not abandon their efforts to acquire new supporters. Segment and Target More Effectively: If response rates drop, tighten your list segmentation to target your most likely supporters. Focus on delivering tailored, relevant messages. Stand Out with a Clear Brand: Donors are more likely to support organizations that present actionable solutions to the causes they care about. Ensure your messaging highlights your unique impact and sets you apart from the competition. Invest in Major Gifts: While smaller donors may be more consistent, major donors are often more sensitive to economic downturns. Strengthening your relationships with key donors is crucial in challenging times. The Importance of Adaptability and Innovation Kathleen also emphasizes the importance of staying flexible and adapting to the economic environment. “Too many groups send out letters that ‘cuss’ at the problems but don’t offer solutions,” she notes. In a competitive landscape, donors gravitate toward organizations with a clear plan for making a difference. Moreover, while some organizations may reduce their outreach efforts or trim acquisition budgets, Kathleen sees opportunities for growth, particularly for those that can demonstrate their ongoing relevance and effectiveness. “Donors are still passionate about causes,” she says, “but they’re looking to support groups that have a real plan to do something.” Key Takeaways for Fundraisers: Prepare, Don’t Panic Economic downturns don’t have to mean disaster for nonprofits. In fact, with the right strategy, organizations can continue to grow. Kathleen’s advice offers a clear roadmap: Don’t stop prospecting for new donors. Lean into your brand and clarify your organization’s value. Strengthen your relationships with major donors. Adapt to the shifting landscape, and don’t shy away from innovating. By taking these proactive steps, fundraisers can continue to make an impact even in difficult economic times. Final Thoughts As we navigate an uncertain economic future, it’s essential for nonprofits to remain focused on their mission while being flexible and strategic in their fundraising efforts. Tough times may test us, but with the right approach, they can also present opportunities for growth.

Facing the Fundraising Storms: How to Prepare

Richard Viguerie, a pioneer in direct marketing, identifies six current challenges for fundraisers, with a seventh on the horizon. These “storms” include: COVID’s lingering effects Donor inflation Postal inflation Gas price hikes Supply chain delays Recession The potential threat of stagflation Despite these challenges, Richard emphasizes that with professional leadership and careful preparation, organizations can navigate through these storms successfully. Next week, we’ll dive into actionable steps to ensure your nonprofit thrives even in tough times.

Surviving the Storms: How to Prepare Your Fundraising for Economic Challenges

Navigating through economic storms can be a daunting task for any organization. But with the right preparation, you can ensure your nonprofit not only survives but thrives. Renowned fundraiser Richard Viguerie outlines several challenges facing fundraisers today, including inflation, recession, and rising postal costs. However, the good news is that a strong, professional approach can get your organization through these storms. Richard’s checklist provides key strategies to keep your fundraising strong and effective, from keeping ample supplies in stock to maximizing donor outreach through postal mail and digital efforts.

How Hospitality Transformed Eleven Madison Park—and Can Transform Your Nonprofit Too

Imagine taking a struggling two-star brasserie in New York City and turning it into the best restaurant in the world. That’s exactly what Will Guidara did with Eleven Madison Park. The secret? Unreasonable hospitality—creating experiences so memorable and personal that they resonate deeply with people. But what does this have to do with fundraising? Everything. Will’s approach to hospitality transcends restaurants and can be applied to the nonprofit world to transform how we build relationships with donors. It’s about more than just providing good service; it’s about making donors feel seen, valued, and deeply connected to your mission. In doing so, you don’t just raise funds—you create lifelong partners. Will’s success at Eleven Madison Park wasn’t just about the food; it was about offering guests an experience they’d remember forever. He calls this “unreasonable hospitality,” and it’s rooted in these three human needs: To be seen To belong To be cared for How can we apply this to our work? By delivering an experience so personal and meaningful that it becomes part of a donor’s story. That might mean surprising them with small acts of appreciation or creating unique opportunities for them to see the direct impact of their contributions. Think about your next donor interaction: how can you make it an unforgettable experience that they’ll want to share and cherish? The path to excellence in fundraising may just lie in creating more meaningful, human connections.

Unreasonable Hospitality: A Key to Transforming Fundraising

Imagine your nonprofit being recognized as the “best in the world” in your field. Sounds incredible, right? But it’s not out of reach. Just as Eleven Madison Park was transformed from a struggling restaurant into the best in the world, you can elevate your organization by embracing the principles of hospitality. Hospitality isn’t just for restaurants. It’s about creating meaningful experiences that make people feel seen, cared for, and valued. When you apply this to fundraising, it goes beyond transactions—it fosters deep, lasting connections with donors, partners, and supporters. People no longer just collect things; they collect experiences. By offering experiences that resonate, you create memories that become part of a donor’s story. Whether it’s personalized thank-yous, special behind-the-scenes tours, or thoughtful gestures that speak to their values, creating an experience is key to transforming relationships and inspiring greater support. What can you do to bring unreasonable hospitality to your cause?

Service is Black and White. Hospitality is Color.

Does that resonate with you? Think about it: service can meet expectations, but hospitality creates experiences that people cherish. We all want to be seen, to belong, and to feel cared for. These simple desires are at the core of hospitality, and when you build a culture that focuses on making people feel welcome and valued, it can transform relationships, not just in restaurants but in any setting, including nonprofit organizations. Creating deeply meaningful and memorable experiences goes beyond efficiency. It’s about making an authentic connection, truly engaging with those you serve, and giving them a sense of belonging. Whether you’re interacting with a generous supporter or creating an experience for someone benefiting from your mission, you have the opportunity to go beyond black-and-white service. You can bring color—hospitality that makes people feel they are part of something bigger. Does that resonate with you? Think about it: service can meet expectations, but hospitality creates experiences that people cherish. We all want to be seen, to belong, and to feel cared for. These simple desires are at the core of hospitality, and when you build a culture that focuses on making people feel welcome and valued, it can transform relationships, not just in restaurants but in any setting, including nonprofit organizations. Creating deeply meaningful and memorable experiences goes beyond efficiency. It’s about making an authentic connection, truly engaging with those you serve, and giving them a sense of belonging. Whether you’re interacting with a generous supporter or creating an experience for someone benefiting from your mission, you have the opportunity to go beyond black-and-white service. You can bring color—hospitality that makes people feel they are part of something bigger.

Sometimes It Just Takes Being Present

What exactly is unreasonable hospitality, and how can it transform our work in nonprofit fundraising and marketing? The key lies in being present, listening carefully, and responding with thoughtful gestures that show our supporters how much we value them. One great story about offering this kind of hospitality came from Will Guidara, a restaurateur, who listened closely to his guests and then went above and beyond their expectations. This level of intentional listening and meaningful action turned a simple meal into a lifelong memory for his guests. How can we apply this approach to our work? It starts by tuning in to what our generous supporters are truly saying. From there, we can create experiences, whether it’s a personal visit, a heartfelt thank-you, or a special event, that align with their interests and contributions. These thoughtful, personal gestures don’t have to be costly—they just have to be meaningful. By offering this kind of hospitality, we can strengthen relationships with our supporters in a way that resonates deeply, making them feel welcome, important, and appreciated.

The Importance of Clear, Actionable Projects in Today’s Fundraising Environment

One of the most significant challenges many organizations are currently facing is how to effectively raise funds in a tough economic climate. While the landscape is tough, the solution isn’t a “one size fits all.” Some organizations are thriving, while others are struggling. What sets successful fundraising efforts apart? The Power of Projects and Specificity One of the key insights that has surfaced is the importance of presenting donors with clear, actionable projects or initiatives. General appeals often fall flat, especially during uncertain times. Donors want to know where their money is going and how it will make a tangible difference. Why a Strong Project Matters It’s not enough to simply call something a project. To truly resonate, your project must be well-defined. This means having: A clear objective: What exactly do you aim to achieve? A budget: How much money will it take to accomplish the goal? A timeline: When will the project be completed? Impact: What measurable difference will this project make? By offering this level of clarity, you make it easier for potential donors to connect with your cause and feel confident in their decision to contribute. Strong Brand + Strong Project = Success A well-established brand helps, but it’s not everything. In this environment, success often comes down to the combination of a strong brand and a strong project. As fundraising becomes more competitive, it’s essential to show donors exactly how their contribution will be used and the impact it will have. A Thoughtful Approach Yields Results At TenX Strategies, we emphasize the importance of aligning your project with donor values. The more you can demonstrate the concrete results of a donor’s gift, the more likely they are to give. Donors are becoming more discerning with their contributions, and they want to be sure that their money will be spent effectively. Key Takeaway: When developing your next fundraising effort, think beyond your organization’s mission. Focus on a specific, actionable project with clear outcomes. This level of detail not only reassures donors but also sets your organization apart in a competitive market.

It’s One of Your Biggest Gaps

And you’re leaving money on the table as a result. What am I talking about? I’m referring to the failure to highlight a special project or initiative to your prospective donors. It’s one of the most common mistakes nonprofits make, and it’s holding you back from Going Big. People are naturally attracted to specificity. Donors don’t just want to hear about the problems you’re addressing—they want to understand your plan to solve them. They want to know if your plan makes sense, if it’s realistic, and if their contribution will make a real difference. Your solution should be the centerpiece of your project. Each of us is passionate about our cause, but we sometimes get so caught up in our mission that we forget to explain the specifics. Donors are sorting through countless requests. They need clarity about your project to feel confident in giving. Do you incorporate special projects into your funding requests? If not, you’re missing a huge opportunity.

Unlimited Free Fundraising Resources